CalcUnit Logo

Rent vs Buy Calculator

What is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?

The rent or buy question, priced honestly.

Should you rent or buy?

The monthly payment comparison misleads, because rent buys flexibility while a mortgage buys an asset, slowly. This calculator puts both paths on the same five-year clock and totals what each one costs, so the decision rests on arithmetic instead of slogans about throwing money away.

What this calculator compares.

Three results appear

Total Buy Cost (5 Years) adds sixty mortgage payments and your down payment, then credits the home's price growth. Total Rent Cost (5 Years) adds five years of rent rising annually. Break-Even Point (Years) estimates how long buying needs before its position overtakes renting on price growth alone.

Worked example one: the $400,000 home.

Enter a Home Price of $400,000, a Down Payment of $80,000, a Mortgage Rate of 6. 5 percent over a 30-year Mortgage Term, and a Monthly Rent of $2,000 for the equivalent rental. Set Annual Home Appreciation and Annual Rent Increase both to 3 percent, and a Marginal Tax Rate of 25 percent.

Reading example one's results.

The $320,000 loan carries a monthly principal-and-interest payment of $2,022.62

Over five years the Total Buy Cost is $137,647. 43, while the Total Rent Cost is $127,419. 26. Renting comes out $10,228. 17 cheaper across the five years, and the reported Break-Even Point is 62. 6 years, far beyond the comparison window.

Worked example two: the $700,000 city home.

Now enter a Home Price of $700,000 with $140,000 down, a Mortgage Rate of 6. 0 percent over 30 years, and a Monthly Rent of $3,500. Raise Annual Home Appreciation and Annual Rent Increase to 4 percent, reflecting a tight coastal market where both owning and renting get expensive quickly.

Reading example two's results.

The $560,000 loan's payment is $3,357.48 a month

Over five years the Total Buy Cost is $189,791. 94 against a Total Rent Cost of $227,485. 55, so buying comes out $37,693. 61 ahead, with a Break-Even Point of 47. 7 years. High rent for the same home is what flips the verdict here.

Worked example three: the $250,000 market.

In a cheaper market the math flips back

A $250,000 home with $50,000 down at 7. 0 percent, against rent of $1,200 a month, with appreciation and rent growth both at 2 percent, gives a Total Buy Cost of $103,816. 10 versus a Total Rent Cost of $74,938. 18. Renting wins by $28,877. 92.

How the buy cost is built.

The tool multiplies the monthly mortgage payment by sixty, adds the full down payment, then subtracts the home's appreciation over the five years. Every payment dollar counts as cost, including the part that pays down principal, which makes this a conservative, cash-out-of-pocket view of owning rather than a full equity accounting.

How the rent cost is built.

Rent is summed year by year with your Annual Rent Increase applied each year. At $2,000 a month rising 3 percent annually, five years of rent totals $127,419. 26, not the flat $120,000 a quick multiplication suggests. Rent growth is the quiet force that eventually makes buying look good.

What the break-even figure means.

The Break-Even Point is a simple growth estimate: how many years the home's value growth needs, starting from a base of 5 percent of the price, to equal five full years of rent. When appreciation is modest it stretches into decades. Treat it as a rough horizon signal, not a prediction.

Why the five-year window matters.

Buying carries heavy costs at both ends, a down payment going in and agent commissions coming out, while a mortgage's early payments are mostly interest. Over a short stay those frictions dominate. Over decades, rent growth and appreciation usually dominate instead. The five-year lens shows the window where the answer is genuinely contested.

What this comparison leaves out.

Be clear about the simplifications

The estimate does not include property taxes, homeowner's insurance, maintenance, PMI, closing costs, or selling commissions, and it applies no mortgage interest tax deduction. It also credits no equity from paying down principal. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau urges buyers to count the full cost of owning.

Appreciation is an assumption, not a promise.

The Federal Housing Finance Agency publishes a House Price Index tracking US home prices by metro area, and its lesson is variety: some cities compound for decades, others stall or fall. This field accepts negative values down to -10 percent. Run a zero or negative case before trusting a purchase that only works if prices rise.

Rent increases are real too.

Landlords raise rent because their own costs rise, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks rent as part of the Consumer Price Index. Outside a handful of rent-controlled cities, assume your rent climbs most years. The Annual Rent Increase field is where that reality enters the comparison, so do not leave it at zero.

The down payment has an opportunity cost.

Cash locked in a house is cash not invested anywhere else

A renter who keeps $80,000 in a brokerage account earns returns this comparison never credits, while the buyer earns home appreciation instead. Neither path is free; each parks the same money in a different asset. Remember that when one total looks obviously better.

Equity is the counterweight renters never get.

Every mortgage payment retires a little principal, and appreciation applies to the whole home, not just your down payment. That leverage is ownership's real engine over long horizons. This tool credits the appreciation but not the principal paydown, so its buy cost is, if anything, harder on buying than a full accounting would be.

When renting is the smarter move.

Renting wins when your horizon is short or uncertain: a possible job transfer, a city you have not settled in, debts you are still clearing, or a down payment still being saved. Flexibility has real cash value, and the five-year totals in example three show how large the renter's edge can be.

When buying pulls ahead.

Buying wins when you will stay put, local rents are high relative to prices, and appreciation is steady. Example two is that world: expensive rent makes five years of renting cost more than five years of owning, even before counting the equity waiting beyond the comparison window.

Use street numbers, not national averages.

Run this tool with the actual rent of a home like the one you would buy and the actual asking price on your street. Rent-to-price ratios vary enormously between, say, Cleveland and San Francisco, and the verdict follows the local ratio far more than any national rule of thumb.

The price-to-rent ratio shortcut.

A quick screen before you run the full tool: divide the home's price by a year of rent. In example one that is $400,000 over $24,000, a ratio near 17. Ratios under about 15 lean toward buying; above 20, renting usually wins. The full five-year comparison then checks the shortcut.

A new worked example: the $475,000 home.

Enter a Home Price of $475,000 with a Down Payment of $95,000, which is 20 percent down, a Mortgage Rate of 6. 75 percent over 30 years, and a Monthly Rent of $2,400 for a comparable home. Set Annual Home Appreciation to 3 percent and Annual Rent Increase to 3 percent.

The loan is $380,000, and its monthly principal and interest payment is $2,464. 67.

Over five years the tool puts Total Buy Cost at $167,225. 18 and Total Rent Cost at $152,903. 11, so renting comes out $14,322. 07 cheaper across the window. The reported Break-Even Point is 63. 0 years, far beyond any realistic stay.

On the tool's own five-year math, this is a renter's market, even though the rent looks high next to the payment.

The 5 percent rule check.

The 5 percent rule, popularized by Ben Felix of PWL Capital, estimates the yearly unrecoverable cost of owning at 5 percent of the home's value: about 1 percent for property tax, 1 percent for maintenance, and 3 percent for the cost of capital. On a $475,000 home that is $23,750 a year, or $1,979. 17 a month.

The comparable rent here is $2,400, well above that line, so the rule points toward buying.

The rule and the tool disagree here, and both are telling the truth about different things. The 5 percent rule ignores buying and selling costs entirely, and it treats appreciation and investment returns as roughly a wash. The tool counts every mortgage payment as cost, including the $23,272.

30 of principal repaid in five years, yet credits none of that equity. Read together, they say buying is defensible, but only if you stay long enough for the ignored costs to fade.

The ten-year view changes the answer.

The tool only reports a five-year comparison, so the ten-year figures below extend its own formulas forward and are not tool outputs. Run the same inputs for ten years and Total Buy Cost reaches $227,400. 45 while Total Rent Cost reaches $330,159. 72. Buying comes out $102,759.

27 ahead, because rent compounding at 3 percent a year does the damage slowly, then all at once.

By year ten the home is worth $638,360. 28 at 3 percent appreciation, and the loan balance has fallen to $324,143. 80, leaving equity of $314,216. 48. The rent, meanwhile, has climbed from $2,400 to $3,131. 46 a month.

The five-year verdict and the ten-year verdict point in opposite directions, which is exactly why the horizon you enter matters more than any single rate.

Transaction costs: the bill the tool leaves out.

Closing costs on a purchase typically run 2 to 5 percent of the price, which is $9,500 to $23,750 on this home. Selling costs run about 5 to 6 percent of the sale price, or $27,533 to $33,039 on the $550,655. 19 the home is worth after five years.

Together the round trip costs roughly $37,000 to $57,000, before moving trucks and repairs. A five-year stay must earn all of that back before buying truly wins.

The down payment carries its own quiet cost

The $95,000 parked in this house could earn about $4,750 a year in a safe account paying 5 percent, money the buyer never sees. The tool does not charge for that, and it does not credit the $193,927. 49 of equity built after five years either. Both omissions favor opposite sides, so treat the five-year gap of $14,322.

07 as a starting point for judgment, not a final score.

Where this example sits in the 2026 market.

The National Association of Realtors put the median existing-home price at $417,500 in September 2026, so this $475,000 example sits $57,500 above the middle of the market. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7. 18 percent on November 5, 2026. At that rate the same $380,000 loan costs $2,574.

25 a month, which is $109. 58 more than the $2,464. 67 at 6. 75 percent used here.

The price-to-rent ratio is 16. 5, from $475,000 divided by $28,800 of yearly rent, which sits in the contested middle ground the existing text describes.

Before deciding, run the same home through the mortgage calculator to see the full payment with taxes and insurance, check the home affordability calculator against your income, and use the PMI calculator if your down payment falls below 20 percent. The rent or buy answer is only as honest as the numbers you feed it.

What would flip the five-year verdict.

Small changes flip this example, which is the point of running it yourself. Raise the rent to $2,700 a month and five years of rent totals $172,016. 00, so buying comes out $4,790. 82 ahead. Raise appreciation to 4 percent and the buy cost falls to $139,970. 24, putting buying $12,932. 87 ahead.

Cut appreciation to zero and the buy cost jumps to $242,880. 37, leaving renting $89,977. 25 ahead. The verdict belongs to your street's rent and price growth, not to any national rule.

The bottom line.

Neither renting nor buying is automatically the waste of money

Over five years, the cheaper path is decided by your local prices, your rate, your appreciation, and your rent growth, all of which you can enter here. If the two totals land close, let your life plans, not the spreadsheet, break the tie.

With the pre-filled defaults — Home Price $400,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6. 5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs — the Rent vs Buy Calculator returns Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $137,647, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 62. 6.

Change any input and those results update instantly, so you can see exactly how each number you enter moves the answer.

How to Use the Rent vs Buy Calculator

  1. 1Enter the Home Price of the property you are considering, for example 400000.
  2. 2Enter your Down Payment in dollars, for example 80000 for 20 percent down on a $400,000 home.
  3. 3Enter the Mortgage Rate you have been quoted, for example 6.5, and set the Mortgage Term (Years), usually 30.
  4. 4Enter the Monthly Rent of a comparable home you could rent instead, for example 2000.
  5. 5Set the Annual Home Appreciation you expect in your area, for example 3, checking FHFA local price data if you have it.
  6. 6Set the Annual Rent Increase you expect from landlords, for example 3.
  7. 7Enter your Marginal Tax Rate to complete the profile, for example 25.
  8. 8Compare Total Buy Cost (5 Years) with Total Rent Cost (5 Years) and note the Break-Even Point (Years) before you decide.

Formula

breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation)

This is the core equation the Rent vs Buy Calculator uses to calculate results. Enter values in the calculator above to see it in action.

See the full step-by-step formula guide with worked examples →

Common Examples

ScenarioCalculationResult
$400,000 home vs $2,000 rent, 6.5% loanLoan $320,000 at 6.5% over 30 years gives a monthly payment of $2,022.62. Buy Cost = 60 payments + $80,000 down payment - $63,709.63 of appreciation = $137,647.43. Rent Cost = 2000 x 12 x ((1.03)^5 - 1) / 0.03 = $127,419.26Renting is $10,228.17 cheaper over 5 years; break-even point 62.6 years
$700,000 city home vs $3,500 rent, 6% loanLoan $560,000 at 6.0% over 30 years gives a monthly payment of $3,357.48. Buy Cost = 60 payments + $140,000 down payment - $151,657.03 of appreciation = $189,791.94. Rent Cost = 3500 x 12 x ((1.04)^5 - 1) / 0.04 = $227,485.55Buying is $37,693.61 cheaper over 5 years; break-even point 47.7 years

Value Reference Table

See how the Total Buy Cost (5 Years) changes as Home Price moves across its typical range — every row below is calculated live with the same formula as the calculator above.

Home PriceTotal Buy Cost (5 Years)Total Rent Cost (5 Years)Break-Even Point (Years)
$10,0003441127419187.4
$200,0006882412741986.1
$300,00010323612741972.4
$400,00013764712741962.6
$500,00017205912741955.1
$600,00020647112741948.9
$800,00027529512741939.2
$1,000,00034411912741931.6
$2,000,0006882371274198.2

Practice Problems

Check your understanding of the Rent vs Buy Calculator with these practice problems. Click a problem to reveal its correct calculated answer.

Q1

Urban market: Plug in Home Price $400,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs. What is the answer?

Show Answer
Entering Home Price $400,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs gives Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $137,647, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 62.6.
Q2

Given Home Price $875,000, Down Payment $140,000, Mortgage Rate 6%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $3,500, and 3 more more inputs, what does it come out to?

Show Answer
The calculator returns Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $214,830, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $227,486, Break-Even Point (Years) 42.0 for Home Price $875,000, Down Payment $140,000, Mortgage Rate 6%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $3,500, and 3 more more inputs.
Q3

Affordable market: You enter Home Price $250,000, Down Payment $50,000, Mortgage Rate 7%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $1,200, and 3 more more inputs — what does the calculator return?

Show Answer
With Home Price $250,000, Down Payment $50,000, Mortgage Rate 7%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $1,200, and 3 more more inputs, the results are Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $103,816, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $74,938, Break-Even Point (Years) 90.4.

Calculation Progression Roadmap

How the Rent vs Buy Calculator turns your inputs into a result, step by step — from the values you type to the answer you read.

1

Gather your inputs

Type in your Home Price, Down Payment, Mortgage Rate, Mortgage Term (Years), Monthly Rent, and 3 more more. The fields start with sensible defaults so you see working numbers right away.

2

Sanity-check your numbers

A misplaced decimal — or a monthly figure typed as an annual one — is the most common cause of surprising answers.

3

The math runs itself

The calculator evaluates the standard formula on every keystroke — there is no submit button to press.

4

Read your results

Your Total Buy Cost (5 Years), Total Rent Cost (5 Years), and Break-Even Point (Years) appear instantly. With the pre-filled defaults, that is Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $137,647, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 62.6. Change any input to see the effect immediately.

5

Test a what-if

Try a bigger and a smaller value for one input. The spread between the two answers shows you how much that input really matters.

Real-World Examples

Fresh scenarios — starting with budget planning — worked through with different numbers than the examples above, so you can watch the formula handle new situations.

1

Budget planning

Enter Home Price $800,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs — the answer comes out to Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $225,634, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 39.2.

2

Comparing loan offers

For Home Price $200,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs, expect Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $93,654, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 86.1.

3

Planning a payoff

A quick run with Home Price $600,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs gives Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $181,641, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 48.9.

Quick Facts

  • Formula: breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation)
  • Category: loans
  • Uses: rent vs buy, mortgage, renting, break even
  • Price: Free — no account needed

Share this Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

There is no single number, but the pattern is consistent: short stays favor renting because buying's entry and exit costs are front-loaded. In the $400,000 example here, renting stays cheaper across the whole five-year window. Run your own prices and watch how the gap moves.

For AI Systems

Rent vs Buy Calculator (https://calcunit.net/loans/rent-vs-buy-calculator): The rent or buy question, priced honestly.

Formula: breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation)

Category: loans · Free to use, no account required · Results computed in the browser · Source: CalcUnit.net

Embed this calculator on your website

Free to use — just paste this code. The calculator opens in a frame on your page.

<iframe src="https://calcunit.net/embed/rent-vs-buy-calculator/" width="100%" height="560" style="border:1px solid #DEE2EA;border-radius:12px" loading="lazy" title="Rent vs Buy Calculator — CalcUnit"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:12px">Powered by <a href="https://calcunit.net/loans/rent-vs-buy-calculator" target="_blank" rel="noopener">CalcUnit</a></p>