CalcUnit Logo

How to Calculate Rent vs Buy

Compare the total cost of renting versus buying a home including appreciation and break-even.

The Formula

breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation)

The rent vs buy formula uses the mathematical relationship: breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation). Each variable in the formula represents a measurable quantity that affects the final result.

What Each Variable Means

Every value in the rent vs buy formula, what it measures, and the value used in the worked example on this page:

VariableTypeExample value
Home PriceInput (you provide)$400,000
Down PaymentInput (you provide)$80,000
Mortgage RateInput (you provide)6.5 %
Mortgage Term (Years)Input (you provide)30
Monthly RentInput (you provide)$2,000
Annual Home AppreciationInput (you provide)3 %
Annual Rent IncreaseInput (you provide)3 %
Marginal Tax RateInput (you provide)25 %
Total Buy Cost (5 Years)Result (calculated)—
Total Rent Cost (5 Years)Result (calculated)—
Break-Even Point (Years)Result (calculated)—

Step-by-Step Method

  1. 1Write down the values you know: Home Price, Down Payment, Mortgage Rate, Mortgage Term (Years), Monthly Rent, Annual Home Appreciation, Annual Rent Increase, Marginal Tax Rate.
  2. 2Substitute your known values into the formula: breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation).
  3. 3Work through the arithmetic in the standard order of operations — parentheses first, then exponents, then multiplication and division, then addition and subtraction.
  4. 4Check that your result carries the correct unit and falls in a reasonable range for the problem.
  5. 5Verify your answer with the interactive Rent vs Buy Calculator — it solves the same formula instantly.

Worked Example

Take a concrete case: home price = $200,000, with the other inputs at the typical values from the variables table above. Substituting into the formula gives total buy cost (5 years) = 68824, total rent cost (5 years) = 127419, break-even point (years) = 86.1. These numbers are solved by the same engine that powers the Rent vs Buy calculator, so you can reproduce them exactly by entering the same inputs there.

Home PriceTotal Buy Cost (5 Years)Total Rent Cost (5 Years)Break-Even Point (Years)
$10,0003441127419187.4
$200,0006882412741986.1
$300,00010323612741972.4
$400,00013764712741962.6
$500,00017205912741955.1
$600,00020647112741948.9
$800,00027529512741939.2
$1,000,00034411912741931.6
$2,000,0006882371274198.2

How each result changes as home price changes, holding the other inputs constant.

Practice Problems

1. Urban market: Plug in Home Price $400,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs. What is the answer?

Answer: Entering Home Price $400,000, Down Payment $80,000, Mortgage Rate 6.5%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $2,000, and 3 more more inputs gives Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $137,647, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $127,419, Break-Even Point (Years) 62.6.

2. Given Home Price $875,000, Down Payment $140,000, Mortgage Rate 6%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $3,500, and 3 more more inputs, what does it come out to?

Answer: The calculator returns Total Buy Cost (5 Years) $214,830, Total Rent Cost (5 Years) $227,486, Break-Even Point (Years) 42.0 for Home Price $875,000, Down Payment $140,000, Mortgage Rate 6%, Mortgage Term (Years) 30, Monthly Rent $3,500, and 3 more more inputs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the formula for rent vs buy?

The formula is: breakEven = log(rentCost/buyCost)/log(1+appreciation). Compare the total cost of renting versus buying a home including appreciation and break-even.

What values do I need to calculate rent vs buy?

You need home price, down payment, mortgage rate, mortgage term (years), monthly rent, annual home appreciation, annual rent increase, marginal tax rate. The calculator produces total buy cost (5 years), total rent cost (5 years), break-even point (years) from those inputs.

What is the rent vs buy when home price is $200,000?

With home price = $200,000, the result is total buy cost (5 years) = 68824, total rent cost (5 years) = 127419, break-even point (years) = 86.1. This is worked through in full in the example on this page.

Related Topics

rent vs buymortgagerentingbreak evenreal estate

Use the Interactive Calculator

Skip the manual math — get instant results with our free Rent vs Buy calculator.

Open Calculator

Related Calculators