Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator
What is the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator?
One decision, made once a year.
Every dollar you put into an IRA forces a single choice: pay tax on it now, or pay tax on it later. A traditional IRA skips the tax today and collects it at withdrawal. A Roth IRA collects the tax today and never asks again. This calculator turns that one choice into two after-tax balances you can compare directly.
What the four result lines mean.
The two pre-tax lines show the raw account balances at retirement
The two after-tax lines show what you can actually spend. For the traditional account, the after-tax line is the honest one, because the IRS owns a slice of every pre-tax dollar. For the Roth, pre-tax and after-tax are identical, because the tax was prepaid.
How this calculator runs the comparison.
Both accounts receive the same gross contribution each year and earn the same return. The traditional side invests the full amount, since no tax is due yet. The Roth side invests the contribution minus today's tax, because that tax is paid out of the same paycheck. Growth then compounds untouched until retirement age.
Worked example one: the tax rate falls in retirement.
Contribute $7,000 a year from age 35 to 65 at a 7 percent return. Your current rate is 22 percent and your retirement rate is 18 percent. The traditional account grows to $661,225. 50 and keeps $542,204. 91 after tax. The Roth invests $5,460 a year after today's tax, grows to $515,755. 89, and keeps all of it.
Reading example one.
The traditional account wins this round by $26,449. 02, and the reason is simple arithmetic. You dodged a 22 percent tax on the way in and paid only 18 percent on the way out. Whenever the rate you avoid today is higher than the rate you pay later, the traditional structure pockets the difference.
Worked example two: the tax rate rises in retirement.
Now start at 30, contribute the same $7,000 for 35 years at 7 percent, but flip the rates: 12 percent today and 22 percent in retirement. The traditional balance reaches $967,658. 15 yet keeps only $754,773. 36 after tax. The Roth balance of $851,539. 17 is entirely yours, so the Roth wins by $96,765. 81.
Worked example three: the same rate both times.
Contribute $6,500 a year from 40 to 65 at a 6 percent return, with a 24 percent tax rate now and later. The traditional account grows to $356,619. 33 and the Roth to $271,030. 69 before tax. After the traditional withdrawal tax, both sides land on exactly $271,030. 69. Equal rates produce an exact tie.
The one rule that decides most cases.
Compare your marginal tax rate today with the rate you honestly expect on retirement withdrawals. Higher today points to traditional. Higher later points to Roth. Early-career workers in the 10 or 12 percent bracket are usually paying the cheapest tax of their lives, which is why advisers so often steer them to the Roth.
The IRS sets the same limit for both.
For 2025, the IRS allows $7,000 of contributions across all your IRAs if you are under 50, plus a $1,000 catch-up at 50 or older. The limit is shared, so every dollar placed in a Roth is a dollar that cannot go into a traditional account. Splitting between the two is allowed and common.
Income can close the Roth door.
Direct Roth contributions phase out at higher incomes
For 2025, the single-filer phase-out runs from $150,000 to $165,000 of modified adjusted gross income, and from $236,000 to $246,000 for married couples filing jointly. Above those ranges, a direct Roth contribution is not permitted, though conversion strategies exist and carry their own tax bills.
The traditional deduction has limits too.
If a workplace plan covers you, the traditional deduction phases out between $79,000 and $89,000 for single filers in 2025, and between $126,000 and $146,000 for joint filers. Without a workplace plan, the deduction is generally available at any income. A nondeductible traditional contribution changes the math, because part of each withdrawal then comes back tax-free.
Required minimum distributions change the endgame.
Traditional IRAs force required minimum distributions, starting at age 73, or 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. Those forced withdrawals are taxable whether you need the money or not. Roth IRAs have no required distributions during the owner's lifetime, so the account can keep compounding for a spouse or for heirs.
What this calculator leaves out.
The model holds one tax rate on each side, while real withdrawals stack on top of Social Security, pensions, and other income, and can climb through several brackets. It also pays the Roth tax out of the contribution. If you can pay that tax from a regular bank account instead, the Roth shelters more money and does better than shown.
Flexibility is the Roth's quiet advantage.
Roth contributions, though never the earnings, can be withdrawn at any age without tax or penalty, because the tax was already paid. Traditional withdrawals before 59 and a half usually face income tax plus a 10 percent penalty. That flexibility makes the Roth a partial emergency reserve, though raiding retirement savings still carries a real opportunity cost.
Estate and Medicare side effects.
Large traditional balances can push retirees into higher Medicare premium tiers through the income-related monthly adjustment amount, and heirs who inherit a traditional IRA generally must empty it within ten years at their own tax rates. Inherited Roth IRAs follow the same ten-year clock, but the withdrawals are tax-free, which is why Roth dollars are prized in estate plans.
Young savers usually hold the strongest Roth card.
A 25-year-old in the 12 percent bracket can lock in that low rate on decades of compounding. Even if retirement brings a similar bracket, the Roth's freedom from required distributions and tax-free withdrawals for heirs keeps it competitive. The cost of choosing Roth early is small, because the tax prepaid at 12 percent is small.
Peak earners usually hold the strongest traditional card.
A household at its career earnings peak might face a 32 or 35 percent marginal rate. Deducting contributions at that rate and withdrawing later at an effective rate in the low twenties is a genuine arbitrage. Business owners with one unusually high-income year often use traditional contributions, or a workplace plan, to blunt that spike.
Conversions are the bridge between the two.
You can move traditional IRA money into a Roth by converting it and paying tax on the amount converted that year. Conversions in low-income years, such as the gap between retirement and claiming Social Security, can be done at unusually low rates. This calculator assumes no conversions, so treat its traditional result as the no-conversion baseline.
State taxes can tip a close call.
The rates in this calculator should be your combined federal and state marginal rates. A worker taxed by California today who retires to a state with no income tax gains extra from the traditional deduction. The reverse move penalizes it. When the federal math is close, the state you work in versus the state you retire in often decides.
A practical way to decide.
Run this calculator twice: once with the retirement rate you expect, and once with a rate five points higher, in case tax law or your income surprises you. If the winner flips between the two runs, splitting contributions between both account types buys you tax diversification, the ability to choose each year of retirement which account to tap.
Worked example four: the same rate both times, at the 2026 limit
Contribute $7,500 a year from age 30 to 65 at a 7 percent return. Your current rate is 22 percent and your retirement rate is 22 percent. The traditional account grows to $1,036,776. 59 and keeps $808,685. 74 after tax. The Roth invests $5,850 a year after today's tax, grows to the same $808,685. 74, and keeps all of it.
When the rate never changes, the two accounts tie exactly. The tie is the point: the entire decision turns on whether your rate rises or falls.
Worked example five: the catch-up years, with a falling rate
Contribute $8,600 a year from age 55 to 65 at a 6 percent return. Your current rate is 24 percent and your retirement rate is 12 percent. The traditional account grows to $113,354. 84 and keeps $99,752. 26 after tax. The Roth invests $6,536 a year after today's tax and grows to $86,149. 68, tax-free.
The traditional account wins this round by $13,602. 58, because dodging a 24 percent tax today and paying 12 percent later beats paying 24 percent up front.
The 2026 limit is higher than this tool's default
This calculator defaults to a $7,000 annual contribution, which was the limit for 2024 and 2025. The IRS raised the 2026 limit to $7,500 in Notice 2025-67, with a $1,100 catch-up at age 50 or older, for a total of $8,600. Example five uses the full catch-up figure.
Anyone planning 2026 contributions should enter $7,500, or $8,600 at 50 or older, not the $7,000 default on this page.
The 2026 income limits moved too
The existing section above quotes the 2025 Roth phase-out ranges. For 2026, direct Roth contributions phase out from $153,000 to $168,000 of modified adjusted gross income for single filers, and from $242,000 to $252,000 for married couples filing jointly, per IRS Notice 2025-67.
Above those ranges, a direct Roth contribution is closed, although a backdoor Roth through a nondeductible traditional contribution and conversion remains available, with the pro-rata rule deciding how much of the conversion is taxed.
Investing the tax saving changes the comparison
The examples above compare the same nominal contribution in each account, which slightly favors the Roth, because a $7,500 traditional contribution costs less out of pocket than a $7,500 Roth contribution. The traditional saver also banks a tax saving each year: $1,650 a year at a 22 percent rate on a $7,500 contribution.
Invested at 7 percent for 35 years, that saving grows to about $228,090. 85 before tax, although capital gains tax trims the gain on withdrawal. A saver who spends the tax saving instead of investing it gives the Roth an unfair head start.
The one rule that decides most cases, restated
Whenever the rate you avoid today is higher than the rate you pay later, the traditional structure pockets the difference. Whenever your retirement rate will be higher, the Roth wins. Young savers in low brackets usually hold the strongest Roth card. Peak earners usually hold the strongest traditional card.
The calculator above runs that comparison in dollars, and the examples show the margin is usually thousands, not hundreds, over a full career.
Splitting the contribution hedges the bet
Unsure which rate applies in retirement, many savers split the contribution. Put $3,750 a year in each account for 30 years at 7 percent, with a 22 percent rate now and 18 percent in retirement. The traditional half grows to $354,227. 95 before tax and keeps $290,466. 92 after tax. The Roth half grows to $276,297. 80, tax-free.
The combined after-tax total is $566,764. 72, between the all-traditional $580,933. 84 and the all-Roth $552,595. 60. The split costs $14,169. 12 against the best guess and buys insurance against being wrong.
The backdoor Roth, in one paragraph
Income above $168,000 for a single filer closes the direct Roth door, but the backdoor remains open: contribute $7,500 nondeductible to a traditional IRA, then convert it to a Roth. The pro-rata rule decides how much of the conversion is taxed.
With $75,000 of pre-tax money already in traditional IRAs, a $7,500 conversion is only 9. 09 percent tax-free, or $681. 82, and the other $6,818. 18 is taxable. The backdoor works cleanly only for savers with no pre-tax IRA balance, which is why many roll old IRAs into a 401k first.
Where to go next
When the comparison is done, run the Roth IRA calculator to model the Roth side alone, the 401k contribution calculator to check the 2026 workplace limit of $24,500, the retirement planner calculator to see the chosen account inside a full retirement projection, and the required minimum distribution calculator to see how the traditional account's withdrawals are eventually forced.
With the pre-filled defaults — Annual Contribution $7,000, Current Age 35, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 22%, Retirement Tax Rate 18%, and 1 more more inputs — the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator returns Years to Retirement 30, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) $661,225. 50, Roth IRA (Pre-tax) $515,755. 89, Traditional IRA (After-tax) $542,204. 91, Roth IRA (After-tax) $515,755. 89.
Change any input and those results update instantly, so you can see exactly how each number you enter moves the answer.
How to Use the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator
- 1Enter your Annual Contribution, for example $7,000, the IRS limit for savers under 50 in 2025.
- 2Enter your Current Age and Retirement Age; the calculator subtracts them to get your Years to Retirement.
- 3Enter your Current Tax Rate, the marginal rate you pay on income today, including state tax if it applies.
- 4Enter your Retirement Tax Rate, your best honest estimate of the rate on withdrawals later.
- 5Enter the Expected Annual Return you think your investments will earn, such as 7 percent.
- 6Read the two pre-tax lines to see the raw balances each account reaches at retirement.
- 7Compare the two after-tax lines; that pair, not the pre-tax pair, is the real verdict.
- 8Change only the Retirement Tax Rate and rerun, to see how sensitive the winner is to your guess.
Formula
This is the core equation the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator uses to calculate results. Enter values in the calculator above to see it in action.
See the full step-by-step formula guide with worked examples →
Common Examples
| Scenario | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Tax rate falls in retirement (22% now, 18% later) | $7,000/yr, ages 35 to 65, 7% return: traditional grows to $661,225.50; Roth invests $5,460/yr after tax and grows to $515,755.89 | Traditional keeps $542,204.91 after tax; Roth keeps $515,755.89 — traditional wins by $26,449.02 |
| Tax rate rises in retirement (12% now, 22% later) | $7,000/yr, ages 30 to 65, 7% return: traditional grows to $967,658.15; Roth grows to $851,539.17 | Traditional keeps $754,773.36 after tax; Roth keeps $851,539.17 — Roth wins by $96,765.81 |
| Same tax rate both times (24% and 24%) | $6,500/yr, ages 40 to 65, 6% return: traditional grows to $356,619.33; Roth grows to $271,030.69 | After tax both sides equal $271,030.69 — an exact tie |
Value Reference Table
See how the Years to Retirement changes as Annual Contribution moves across its typical range — every row below is calculated live with the same formula as the calculator above.
| Annual Contribution | Years to Retirement | Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) | Roth IRA (Pre-tax) | Traditional IRA (After-tax) | Roth IRA (After-tax) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $2,000 | 30 | 188921.57 | 147358.83 | 154915.69 | 147358.83 |
| $4,000 | 30 | 377843.15 | 294717.65 | 309831.38 | 294717.65 |
| $5,000 | 30 | 472303.93 | 368397.07 | 387289.22 | 368397.07 |
| $7,000 | 30 | 661225.50 | 515755.89 | 542204.91 | 515755.89 |
| $9,000 | 30 | 850147.08 | 663114.72 | 697120.60 | 663114.72 |
| $10,000 | 30 | 944607.86 | 736794.13 | 774578.45 | 736794.13 |
| $20,000 | 30 | 1889215.73 | 1473588.27 | 1549156.90 | 1473588.27 |
| $30,000 | 30 | 2833823.59 | 2210382.40 | 2323735.34 | 2210382.40 |
Practice Problems
Check your understanding of the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator with these practice problems. Click a problem to reveal its correct calculated answer.
Lower retirement tax: Plug in Annual Contribution $7,000, Current Age 35, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 22%, Retirement Tax Rate 18%, and 1 more more inputs. What is the answer?
Show AnswerHide Answer
Given Annual Contribution $8,750, Current Age 30, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 12%, Retirement Tax Rate 22%, and 1 more more inputs, what does it come out to?
Show AnswerHide Answer
Same tax bracket: You enter Annual Contribution $6,500, Current Age 40, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 24%, Retirement Tax Rate 24%, and 1 more more inputs — what does the calculator return?
Show AnswerHide Answer
Calculation Progression Roadmap
How the Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator turns your inputs into a result, step by step — from the values you type to the answer you read.
Gather your inputs
Type in your Annual Contribution, Current Age, Retirement Age, Current Tax Rate, Retirement Tax Rate, and 1 more more. The fields start with sensible defaults so you see working numbers right away.
Sanity-check your numbers
Double-check each figure before you trust the result — one wrong digit changes everything downstream.
The math runs itself
The calculator evaluates Retirement Age - Current Age on every keystroke — there is no submit button to press.
Read your results
Your Years to Retirement, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax), Roth IRA (Pre-tax), Traditional IRA (After-tax), and Roth IRA (After-tax) appear instantly. With the pre-filled defaults, that is Years to Retirement 30, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) $661,225.50, Roth IRA (Pre-tax) $515,755.89, Traditional IRA (After-tax) $542,204.91, Roth IRA (After-tax) $515,755.89. Change any input to see the effect immediately.
Test a what-if
Change a single input and watch which outputs move. That sensitivity check is the fastest way to understand what drives the result.
Real-World Examples
Fresh scenarios — starting with annual review — worked through with different numbers than the examples above, so you can watch the formula handle new situations.
Annual review
Enter Annual Contribution $14,000, Current Age 35, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 22%, Retirement Tax Rate 18%, and 1 more more inputs — the answer comes out to Years to Retirement 30, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) $1,322,451.01, Roth IRA (Pre-tax) $1,031,511.79, Traditional IRA (After-tax) $1,084,409.83, Roth IRA (After-tax) $1,031,511.79.
On-track check
For Annual Contribution $3,500, Current Age 35, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 22%, Retirement Tax Rate 18%, and 1 more more inputs, expect Years to Retirement 30, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) $330,612.75, Roth IRA (Pre-tax) $257,877.95, Traditional IRA (After-tax) $271,102.46, Roth IRA (After-tax) $257,877.95.
What-if scenario
A quick run with Annual Contribution $10,500, Current Age 35, Retirement Age 65, Current Tax Rate 22%, Retirement Tax Rate 18%, and 1 more more inputs gives Years to Retirement 30, Traditional IRA (Pre-tax) $991,838.26, Roth IRA (Pre-tax) $773,633.84, Traditional IRA (After-tax) $813,307.37, Roth IRA (After-tax) $773,633.84.
Quick Facts
- Formula:
rothAdvantage = rothBalance - traditionalAfterTax - Category: retirement
- Uses: IRA, Roth IRA, Traditional IRA, tax comparison
- Price: Free — no account needed
Frequently Asked Questions
Neither. With equal rates the two accounts finish with identical after-tax values, as the third worked example shows. In that case the Roth's side benefits usually break the tie: no required minimum distributions, tax-free withdrawals for heirs, and penalty-free access to your contributions at any age.
For AI Systems
Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator (https://calcunit.net/retirement/traditional-ira-vs-roth-ira-calculator): One decision, made once a year.
Formula: rothAdvantage = rothBalance - traditionalAfterTax
Category: retirement · Free to use, no account required · Results computed in the browser · Source: CalcUnit.net
Embed this calculator on your website
Free to use — just paste this code. The calculator opens in a frame on your page.
<iframe src="https://calcunit.net/embed/traditional-ira-vs-roth-ira-calculator/" width="100%" height="560" style="border:1px solid #DEE2EA;border-radius:12px" loading="lazy" title="Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Calculator — CalcUnit"></iframe> <p style="font-size:12px">Powered by <a href="https://calcunit.net/retirement/traditional-ira-vs-roth-ira-calculator" target="_blank" rel="noopener">CalcUnit</a></p>
