CalcUnit Logo

Loan Comparison Calculator

What is the Loan Comparison Calculator?

What this calculator does.

It places two loans for the same amount side by side and prices each one three ways: the monthly payment, the total interest over the life of the loan, and the total cost. Then it shows the interest difference in plain dollars.

The three numbers that decide a loan.

Monthly payment decides whether the loan fits your budget

Total interest decides what the borrowing truly costs. Total cost is the two views combined over time. Shoppers who look only at the payment routinely buy the more expensive loan.

The inputs, in plain English.

One Loan Amount is shared by both offers

Loan 1 and Loan 2 each get an Interest Rate and a Term in Years. That covers the classic contests: short term against long term, or one lender's rate against another's.

Reading the results.

Each loan reports its Monthly Payment, Total Cost, and Total Interest

The Interest Difference line at the end is the headline: it is the extra lifetime interest one loan charges over the other, stated as a single dollar figure.

Worked example one: thirty years against fifteen.

Enter a Loan Amount of $300,000

Loan 1 is 6. 5 percent for 30 years; Loan 2 is 7. 0 percent for 15 years, the typical pattern of a shorter term carrying a slightly higher rate in this comparison.

What example one produces.

Loan 1 costs $1,896.20 a month and $382,633.47 in total interest

Loan 2 costs $2,696. 48 a month but only $185,367. 27 in interest. The Interest Difference is $197,266. 20, nearly two hundred thousand dollars.

What example one really says.

The 15-year loan demands $800. 28 more every month, and in exchange it erases almost $200,000 of interest. Neither answer is automatically right: the cheaper loan is only cheaper if the payment survives your worst month, not your best one.

Worked example two: three quarters of a point.

Enter $250,000 with both terms at 30 years

Loan 1 is 6. 0 percent, Loan 2 is 6. 75 percent. The payments are $1,498. 88 and $1,621. 50, a gap of just $122. 62 a month that is easy to wave away at a closing table.

Why small rate gaps are not small.

Over 360 payments, that waved-away gap becomes $44,142. 81 of extra interest: $333,738. 29 against $289,595. 47. Rate shopping feels tedious precisely because each tenth of a point looks trivial monthly while quietly compounding into a year of salary over the loan's life.

Worked example three: when the higher rate wins.

Enter a $20,000 personal loan

Loan 1 is 8. 0 percent over 5 years at $405. 53 a month. Loan 2 is 10. 0 percent over 3 years at $645. 34 a month. The higher-rate loan costs less overall, $3,232. 37 of interest against $4,331. 67.

The lesson in example three.

Term can overpower rate

Stretching a loan gives interest more years to work, so a cheaper rate on a longer loan can cost more than a pricier rate repaid quickly. That is why the Interest Difference, not the rate, is the scoreboard.

The CFPB's advice on comparing loans.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau urges borrowers to compare more than the monthly payment: request Loan Estimates from several lenders, compare APR and total cost over the loan's life, and ask about fees. This calculator gives you the payment-versus-interest half of that homework instantly.

What this calculator leaves out.

It compares interest rates, not APRs, and it includes no lender fees, discount points, closing costs, or origination charges. Two loans with identical rates can still differ by thousands in fees, so treat the winner here as the finalist, then compare full Loan Estimates.

Questions to ask before you sign.

Is there a prepayment penalty if you pay extra or pay off early? Are fees being rolled into the balance, quietly raising the amount you finance? Does the rate ever adjust? Each answer can overturn a comparison that looked settled on interest alone.

Match the loan to your horizon.

Total interest assumes you keep the loan to its final payment

If you will likely move or refinance within seven years, a 30-year loan's lifetime interest overstates your real cost, and the monthly payment deserves more weight in the decision.

The cash-flow test.

A loan you cannot comfortably pay in a bad month is not cheaper at any interest total. Missed payments bring late fees, credit damage, and default risk that dwarf the savings on paper. Run the winner's payment against your leanest realistic budget before committing.

Refinancing is the same comparison.

Put your current loan in as Loan 1 and the refinance offer as Loan 2, using your remaining balance as the Loan Amount and the remaining years as Loan 1's term. The Interest Difference shows the gross saving, before the refi's closing costs.

Adjustable-rate loans break this comparison.

Every figure here assumes the rate you enter survives the whole term

An adjustable-rate mortgage resets after its fixed window, making lifetime interest unknowable in advance. Compare an ARM against fixed loans on its opening years only, and only if you would sell or refinance before the first adjustment.

Discount points change the rate you should enter.

Paying points buys a lower rate, so enter the bought-down rate for that offer. The points themselves are a fee this calculator cannot see, so add their cost to your mental total for that loan. The CFPB's Loan Estimate lays points and lender credits out in dollars.

Extra principal rewrites the term.

Paying more than the required payment shortens a loan's real life and cuts its interest, without any paperwork. To approximate the effect here, rerun the loan with a shorter term and compare: the interest shown for the shorter schedule is close to what disciplined extra payments achieve.

Comparing loans of different amounts.

This tool holds one Loan Amount for both offers, which is how honest comparisons work. If one lender finances closing costs into the balance while the other wants cash at closing, the amounts are no longer equal, so adjust by comparing the financed-fee version at its true, higher balance.

Your credit score moves both offers.

The rates in any quote already reflect your credit profile, and a score improvement of 40 points can shift the rates lenders offer on both sides of this comparison. If your score is close to a pricing tier, a few months of cleanup before applying can beat weeks of lender shopping.

The break-even habit for refinances.

Divide the refinance's closing costs by the monthly payment saving and you get the months needed to profit from the switch. If you might move before that month arrives, the apparently cheaper Loan 2 is actually the expensive one, whatever the Interest Difference says.

The same rate, different terms.

The most useful comparison on this page holds the rate steady and changes only the term. Borrow $400,000 at 6. 25 percent and compare 30 years against 20. The 30-year payment is $2,462. 87 a month and the total interest is $486,632. 77. The 20-year payment is $2,923. 71 and the total interest is $301,691. 07.

The shorter term costs $460. 84 more a month but saves $184,941. 69 in interest and ends the loan a decade sooner. That is the whole trade in two numbers, and it is the comparison most borrowers never run because the two offers arrive from different lenders on different days.

If the 20-year payment fits your budget with room to spare, take it. If it does not fit, take the 30-year loan and pay the difference as extra principal when you can. The calculator cannot force the habit, but it can show you exactly what the habit is worth.

The lender-credit trade.

Lenders often offer to pay your closing costs in exchange for a higher rate, and the trade is easy to get wrong. Take a $300,000 loan over 30 years. At 6. 5 percent with no credit, the payment is $1,896. 20 and the total interest is $382,633. 47. At 6.

75 percent with a $3,000 lender credit, the payment is $1,945. 79 and the total interest is $400,485. 94.

The higher rate costs $49.59 more a month

The $3,000 credit covers that gap for about 60. 5 months, just over five years. Keep the loan longer than five years and the credit loses: over 30 years the higher rate costs $17,852. 48 in extra interest for a $3,000 saving at closing.

The rule is simple

Divide the credit by the monthly payment gap. That is your break-even in months. If you will sell or refinance before then, take the credit. If you will stay longer, take the lower rate. Run both offers through this page and the discount points calculator before you choose.

The smaller loan can win even at a higher rate.

Most comparisons hold the amount steady, but real life rarely does

A smaller loan at a higher rate can cost less overall than a bigger loan at a lower rate, because the amount matters as much as the rate. Compare $300,000 at 6. 5 percent over 30 years with $250,000 at 7. 5 percent over 30 years.

The bigger, cheaper-rate loan costs $1,896. 20 a month and $382,633. 47 in total interest. The smaller, higher-rate loan costs $1,748. 04 a month and $379,293. 06 in total interest. The smaller loan wins on both numbers, saving $148. 16 a month and $3,340. 41 in interest, even though its rate is a full point higher.

That is why a bigger down payment beats a slightly lower rate in most real comparisons. Every dollar you do not borrow is a dollar that never accrues interest at any rate or term.

Before you compare rates, compare amounts, and check the result against the house affordability calculator to see what the smaller loan means for the house you can buy.

The refinance comparison.

Refinancing is the same comparison with different labels: the old loan against the new one. Take a $300,000 balance at 7. 5 percent over 30 years. The payment is $2,097. 64 a month and the total interest is $455,151. 67. Refinance to 6. 5 percent over 30 years and the payment is $1,896. 20, with total interest of $382,633. 47.

The new loan saves $201.44 a month

The closing costs are $6,000, so the break-even is 29. 8 months, about two and a half years. Stay longer than that and the refinance wins: over the full 30 years the interest saved is $72,518. 20, minus the $6,000 in costs, for a net saving of $66,518. 20.

Move or refinance again before month 30 and the refinance loses, because the $6,000 was spent and the monthly savings never caught up. That is the whole refinance decision in one division: closing costs divided by monthly saving. If your horizon is longer than the answer, refinance. If it is shorter, keep the old loan and pay extra principal instead.

Ask for the Loan Estimate, not the quote.

A verbal rate quote is not a comparison

Under federal rules a mortgage lender must send a Loan Estimate within three business days of your application, and that form is the document to compare. It lists the rate, the monthly payment, the closing costs, and the APR in the same format from every lender.

Run each Loan Estimate through this page, one loan at a time, and write down the total interest for each. The lender with the lowest payment is not always the lender with the lowest total cost, and the Loan Estimate is what exposes the gap.

Keep the estimates, compare them side by side, and let the refinance calculator price the break-even before you pay a single fee.

The 15-year fixed against the 30-year fixed, same lender.

The starkest comparison on this page uses the same lender, the same amount, and two different terms. Borrow $300,000. Over 30 years at 6. 5 percent the payment is $1,896. 20 a month and the total interest is $382,633. 47. Over 15 years at 6. 0 percent the payment is $2,531. 57 and the total interest is $155,682. 69.

The shorter loan costs $635. 37 more a month and saves $226,950. 78 in interest. It also ends fifteen years sooner, which means fifteen years with no mortgage payment at all, and fifteen years of the same money going to savings instead. The 15-year loan is not just cheaper. It is a different life.

Most buyers cannot carry the 15-year payment, and that is fine

Take the 30-year loan, pay the 15-year amount whenever you can, and watch the amortization schedule move. The comparison is not about which loan to sign. It is about knowing what the cheaper payment really costs, so the choice is yours and not the lender's.

The bottom line.

Compare loans on total interest for cost, on monthly payment for survival, and on fees with the lender's own paperwork. When all three point the same way, you have found the right loan; when they disagree, the Interest Difference tells you the price of comfort.

With the pre-filled defaults — Loan Amount $300,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6. 5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15 — the Loan Comparison Calculator returns Loan 1 Monthly Payment $1,896. 20, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $2,696. 48, Loan 1 Total Cost $682,633. 47, Loan 2 Total Cost $485,367.

27, Loan 1 Total Interest $382,633. 47, and 2 more more results. Change any input and those results update instantly, so you can see exactly how each number you enter moves the answer.

How to Use the Loan Comparison Calculator

  1. 1Enter the Loan Amount both offers share, for example 300000.
  2. 2Enter the Loan 1 Interest Rate as a yearly percent, for example 6.5.
  3. 3Enter the Loan 1 Term in Years, for example 30.
  4. 4Enter the Loan 2 Interest Rate, for example 7.0.
  5. 5Enter the Loan 2 Term in Years, for example 15 for a short-term alternative.
  6. 6Compare the Loan 1 and Loan 2 Monthly Payments against your budget first.
  7. 7Compare Total Cost and Total Interest for each loan to see the lifetime price of each offer.
  8. 8Read the Interest Difference for the final verdict, then check fees and APR on the winning lender's Loan Estimate.

Formula

payment = P*(r*(1+r)^n)/((1+r)^n-1)

This is the core equation the Loan Comparison Calculator uses to calculate results. Enter values in the calculator above to see it in action.

See the full step-by-step formula guide with worked examples →

Common Examples

ScenarioCalculationResult
$300,000 mortgage: 30 years at 6.5% vs 15 years at 7.0%Loan Amount $300,000; Loan 1 at 6.5% for 30 years; Loan 2 at 7.0% for 15 years; standard amortization payment formula applied to eachLoan 1: $1,896.20/mo, total interest $382,633.47. Loan 2: $2,696.48/mo, total interest $185,367.27. Interest Difference $197,266.20
$250,000 mortgage: 6.0% vs 6.75%, both 30 yearsLoan Amount $250,000; Loan 1 at 6.0% for 30 years; Loan 2 at 6.75% for 30 years; standard amortization payment formula applied to eachLoan 1: $1,498.88/mo, total interest $289,595.47. Loan 2: $1,621.50/mo, total interest $333,738.29. Interest Difference $44,142.81
$20,000 personal loan: 8% over 5 years vs 10% over 3 yearsLoan Amount $20,000; Loan 1 at 8.0% for 5 years; Loan 2 at 10.0% for 3 years; standard amortization payment formula applied to eachLoan 1: $405.53/mo, total interest $4,331.67. Loan 2: $645.34/mo, total interest $3,232.37. Interest Difference $1,099.30

Value Reference Table

See how the Loan 1 Monthly Payment changes as Loan Amount moves across its typical range — every row below is calculated live with the same formula as the calculator above.

Loan AmountLoan 1 Monthly PaymentLoan 2 Monthly PaymentLoan 1 Total CostLoan 2 Total CostLoan 1 Total InterestLoan 2 Total InterestInterest Difference
$1,0006.328.992275.441617.891275.44617.89657.55
$200,0001264.141797.66455088.98323578.18255088.98123578.18131510.80
$300,0001896.202696.48682633.47485367.27382633.47185367.27197266.20
$400,0002528.273595.31910177.95647156.36510177.95247156.36263021.60
$500,0003160.344494.141137722.44808945.44637722.44308945.44328777.00
$600,0003792.415392.971365266.93970734.53765266.93370734.53394532.40
$800,0005056.547190.631820355.911294312.711020355.91494312.71526043.20
$900,0005688.618089.452047900.401456101.801147900.40556101.80591798.60
$1,000,0006320.688988.282275444.881617890.891275444.88617890.89657554.00

Practice Problems

Check your understanding of the Loan Comparison Calculator with these practice problems. Click a problem to reveal its correct calculated answer.

Q1

30yr vs 15yr mortgage: You enter Loan Amount $300,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6.5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15 — what does the calculator return?

Show Answer
The calculator returns Loan 1 Monthly Payment $1,896.20, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $2,696.48, Loan 1 Total Cost $682,633.47, Loan 2 Total Cost $485,367.27, Loan 1 Total Interest $382,633.47, and 2 more more results for Loan Amount $300,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6.5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15.
Q2

With Loan Amount $312,500, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 6.75%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 30, what are the results?

Show Answer
With Loan Amount $312,500, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 6.75%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 30, the results are Loan 1 Monthly Payment $1,873.60, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $2,026.87, Loan 1 Total Cost $674,494.34, Loan 2 Total Cost $729,672.86, Loan 1 Total Interest $361,994.34, and 2 more more results.
Q3

Personal loan options: Loan Amount $20,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 8%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 5, Loan 2 Interest Rate 10%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 3 — work it out, then check the answer.

Show Answer
Entering Loan Amount $20,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 8%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 5, Loan 2 Interest Rate 10%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 3 gives Loan 1 Monthly Payment $405.53, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $645.34, Loan 1 Total Cost $24,331.67, Loan 2 Total Cost $23,232.37, Loan 1 Total Interest $4,331.67, and 2 more more results.

Calculation Progression Roadmap

How the Loan Comparison Calculator turns your inputs into a result, step by step — from the values you type to the answer you read.

1

Gather your inputs

Type in your Loan Amount, Loan 1 Interest Rate, Loan 1 Term (Years), Loan 2 Interest Rate, and Loan 2 Term (Years). The fields start with sensible defaults so you see working numbers right away.

2

Sanity-check your numbers

Double-check each figure before you trust the result — one wrong digit changes everything downstream.

3

The math runs itself

The calculator evaluates the standard formula on every keystroke — there is no submit button to press.

4

Read your results

Your Loan 1 Monthly Payment, Loan 2 Monthly Payment, Loan 1 Total Cost, Loan 2 Total Cost, Loan 1 Total Interest, and 2 more more appear instantly. With the pre-filled defaults, that is Loan 1 Monthly Payment $1,896.20, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $2,696.48, Loan 1 Total Cost $682,633.47, Loan 2 Total Cost $485,367.27, Loan 1 Total Interest $382,633.47, and 2 more more results. Change any input to see the effect immediately.

5

Test a what-if

Change a single input and watch which outputs move. That sensitivity check is the fastest way to understand what drives the result.

Real-World Examples

Fresh scenarios — starting with planning a payoff — worked through with different numbers than the examples above, so you can watch the formula handle new situations.

1

Planning a payoff

A quick run with Loan Amount $600,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6.5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15 gives Loan 1 Monthly Payment $3,792.41, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $5,392.97, Loan 1 Total Cost $1,365,266.93, Loan 2 Total Cost $970,734.53, Loan 1 Total Interest $765,266.93, and 2 more more results.

2

Affordability check

With Loan Amount $150,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6.5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15, the calculator returns Loan 1 Monthly Payment $948.10, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $1,348.24, Loan 1 Total Cost $341,316.73, Loan 2 Total Cost $242,683.63, Loan 1 Total Interest $191,316.73, and 2 more more results.

3

Refinance math

Plug in Loan Amount $450,000, Loan 1 Interest Rate 6.5%, Loan 1 Term (Years) 30, Loan 2 Interest Rate 7%, Loan 2 Term (Years) 15 and you get Loan 1 Monthly Payment $2,844.31, Loan 2 Monthly Payment $4,044.73, Loan 1 Total Cost $1,023,950.20, Loan 2 Total Cost $728,050.90, Loan 1 Total Interest $573,950.20, and 2 more more results.

Quick Facts

  • Formula: payment = P*(r*(1+r)^n)/((1+r)^n-1)
  • Category: loans
  • Uses: loan comparison, mortgage, monthly payment, total interest
  • Price: Free — no account needed

Share this Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

No. A lower payment usually means a longer term, and more years of interest. In the $300,000 example here, the loan with the lower payment, $1,896. 20, costs $197,266. 20 more in lifetime interest than the $2,696. 48 loan. Judge cost by total interest, and judge fit by the payment.

For AI Systems

Loan Comparison Calculator (https://calcunit.net/loans/loan-comparison-calculator): What this calculator does.

Formula: payment = P*(r*(1+r)^n)/((1+r)^n-1)

Category: loans · Free to use, no account required · Results computed in the browser · Source: CalcUnit.net

Embed this calculator on your website

Free to use — just paste this code. The calculator opens in a frame on your page.

<iframe src="https://calcunit.net/embed/loan-comparison-calculator/" width="100%" height="560" style="border:1px solid #DEE2EA;border-radius:12px" loading="lazy" title="Loan Comparison Calculator — CalcUnit"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:12px">Powered by <a href="https://calcunit.net/loans/loan-comparison-calculator" target="_blank" rel="noopener">CalcUnit</a></p>